Murder Mystery Dinner Theater
Not Favorite

Performing & Visual Arts

Murder Mystery Dinner Theater

wallert

$105.00

December 2025
Availability :
Good Availability
Limited Availability
Low Availability
Sold Out
Sun
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat
 
 
 
 
 
Calender...

A 1920s Murder Mystery Dinner Experience\nPresented by Wanderlustory Events x The Murder Mystery Company

What to Expect:

A live interactive performance full of suspects, secrets, and surprise twists

You’ll be assigned a character or role when you arrive — don’t worry, it’s optional but so fun!

A classic 1920s speakeasy setting. Costumes are encouraged (feathers, suspenders, pearls, etc.)

And of course… a murder to solve


Tickets start at $105 per person — BUT if you join my group, you’ll save up to 30% off your ticket!

Limited spots available — once we’re full, the mystery begins without you. We will meet on January 18, 2026 and March 8, 2026 (my birthday!)

Join me for an unforgettable night of food, murder and mystery.

What’s Included:

Three-Course Dinner at Carmine’s – classic family-style Italian favorites in an iconic Times Square setting

Live Theatrical Performance – professionally acted murder mystery show by The Murder Mystery Company

Character Role Assignment – optional roles for guests who want to participate in the investigation

Interactive Clues & Mystery Solving – gather hints, interrogate suspects, and work as a team

Costumes Encouraged – throw on your flapper dresses, suspenders, fedoras, and pearls (but it’s not required!)


Let’s sip, solve, and slay the case in style.


Perfect for:

  • Date nights that break the dinner-and-a-movie cycle
  • Girls night out with drama and pasta
  • Birthday or celebration events with flair
  • Solo adventurers who want something fun + new
  • Anyone obsessed with Clue, Knives Out, or murder podcasts
Find Ticket

200 West 44th Street, New York, NY 10036

Jan 18, 2026 to Jan 19, 2026 -5:00 PM